Pakistan’s defence minister recently hit at Israel as a British creation. Since Israel’s independence, Pakistan has been one of the most hostile nations toward the State of Israel. Pakistani defence ministers and many other leaders have attacked Israel for decades and even called for its destruction. Khawaja Asif called Israel “evil and a curse for humanity” and a “cancerous state.” He wrote that he hoped “people who created this cancerous state on Palestinian land to get rid of European jews burn in hell.” He called Israel an illegitimate product of the Balfour Declaration and demanded that Muslim countries form a united military front against it. Other Pakistani leaders and parliamentarians have openly talked of wiping Israel out, using nuclear weapons, and declaring jihad. That language is not new. It is the normal language from that side.
Yet Pakistan forgets one very important thing. It is pointing at the British while standing on British ground itself. Israel is mentioned in the Bible. Israel, Bani Israel is mentioned in the Quran at least forty times. The Western Wall, the City of David, inscriptions, coins, and layers of archaeology prove a Jewish civilisation in that land long before modern politics. The Jewish people did not appear in 1948. They returned to a place their texts, their memory, and the ground itself already named.
Pakistan was not a thing even in the 1930s. Pakistan was a personal project. It has no ancient history as a state. The land itself obviously has history. That history was much closer to Buddhist civilisations like Gandhara than to anything Islamic. That is a bit offensive to say. It is also the honest truth.
Pakistan’s creation rested on just four people. Just four.
One of them was very ill and had to hide it from everyone. If the others had known, the biggest man among them could have cancelled the whole project in a second. That sick man was Muhammad Ali Jinnah. His doctor had already told him the lungs were failing and that he had, at most, a couple of years. Jinnah buried the diagnosis. Public knowledge of the illness would have wrecked his leverage.
The second man was paid a few thousand Indian rupees to draw the border. Sir Cyril Radcliffe barely knew the land. He was given weeks, not years. He drew lines on maps and left. Those lines became the frontier.
The third man was the opposition and the man behind independent India: Jawaharlal Nehru. Mountbatten and Nehru were close. Both preferred one united India. That option was real until Jinnah made partition the price of leaving.
The fourth and biggest of them all was the true father of modern Pakistan: Lord Mountbatten, representative of the British Empire and the royal family. He wanted a clean, fast exit. Jinnah wanted a separate state. Mountbatten delivered it.
Just these four. That is the core of Pakistan’s founding story. Pakistan is the only country whose comprehensive political birth I can write on one A4 sheet in medium font. This is to remind the Pakistani defence minister of the history he forgot. No amount of Mecca alliance missiles, anti-Israel rhetoric, and arrogance can hide it.
Pakistan is an accident. It is the result of a deal among a handful of men.
Mountbatten arrived as Viceroy wanting to free one India. Nehru was his closest political friend. Their aims lined up. A united successor state was possible. Then Jinnah walked into the middle of it. Mountbatten and Jinnah also had a working relationship. Jinnah dressed English, spoke English, lived English. He was a product of the colonial system, and British officers found him easier to deal with than many others. Because Jinnah refused to settle for anything less than a separate Muslim state, the British Empire under Mountbatten created the Pakistan we see today.
While this was happening, Jinnah’s doctor told him the truth about his body. He had been ill for a long time. At most he had two years. Jinnah hid the illness completely. The latest report stayed secret. The main reason was simple. If Mountbatten had learned how sick Jinnah was — or if Nehru had learned it — Mountbatten would not have rushed a country called Pakistan into existence. Pakistan exists because Jinnah was still standing in 1947 and because nobody in power knew he was dying.
On 14 August 1947 the border drawn by Radcliffe became Jinnah’s gift under Mountbatten’s leadership. Pakistan was born.
Exactly one year and one month later, on 11 September 1948, Jinnah died of tuberculosis and lung cancer. Years afterward, when a journalist asked Mountbatten about Jinnah’s death and the hidden illness, Mountbatten said the line that still sits over the whole story:
“If I had known it at that time, history would have been completely different. I had the ability to delay giving independence to India by several months. If that happened, Pakistan would never have been created.”
A defence minister who calls Israel a British invention should first read how his own country was invented by a dying lawyer, a hurried English lawyer with a pencil, an Indian rival who wanted unity, and a British viceroy in a hurry to go home.
